In my thinking. its all the same language as Punajbi and only a variant of great Punjabi language.

Just a few thousand ppl speaking a dialect doesnt make it a language and sraiki has not history, no culture or background. Nobody knows abt it in the world.

I think we must all unite together to promote Punjabi which is our real language and known worldwide.

Please stop these regional websites..

Rana Aslam Ramzan
Lect.
Govt. College University, Faisalabad

rana sahib,
we know we are it is enough.we have no time to discuss a settled issue.it is not your problem.your punjabi nation emerged and ended with your ist and last ruler Ranjeet Singh who is established villain near Seraikies. what is your national issue? we are not ready to be part of punjabi chauvinism. plz. do your own bussiness. ijaz bloach

Mr. Rana,

I have read your comments on Saraiki Language. I am astonished to read such kinds of comments on the LARGEST spoken language of Pakistan which has its own history, cultural assets and language background. According to one survey, Saraiki Literature is the most published one for many years after Urdu Literature. I think you have not visited the cities of Saraiki Wasaib and just roaming about Lahor and Faisal Abad. So plz stop this abuse of great regional language of Pakistan.

May Allah grant you wisdom.

With regards.
FAROOQ AHMED DHAREJA....Multan

Pleasee do not change the national facts. Punjabi is the largest spoken language of Pakistan and also has a great culture and history.

1) What is Sraiki culture? can you tell me one famous hero that you have produced in centuries except Fuedals and Mukhtaran Mai.

2) How you say more books published in Sraiki? Do you have any facts or just saying?

3) How you say Sraiki is different from Punjabi. We think its just a dialect.

4) You say you have a different culture? what is so different - its all the same from Lahore to Rajanpur.

Differences are not good for our country.

Mr. Rana.

Saraiki has its own grammer and Phoetics.

IN 1998, ACADMY ADBIYAT PUBLISHED A REPORT IN WHICH IT IS STATED THAT AFTER URDU SERAIKI LITERATURE IS THE MORE PUBLISHED ONE THAN ANY OTHER PAKISTANI LANGUAGE.

If u want to know about HEROEs of saraiki, read Akram Mirani's Book "ASADA DES".

IF U WANT TO READ ABOUT SERAIKI CULTURE, THEN READ FIDA HUSSAIN GADI'S BOOK "SERAIKI CULTURE.

SERAIKI IS TAUGHT IN 2 UNIVERISITES OF PAKISTAN AT BACHELOR AND MASTER LEVEL, IT MEANS THAT THIS IS THE COMPLETELY DIFFERENT LANGAUAGE HAVING ITS OWN GRAMMER AND EVERYTHING WHICH IS REQURED.

DR. C. SHECKEL, GEORGE GRESON AND SOMERNOF HAVE ALSO RECOGNIZED IT AS A DIFFERENT LANGUAGE FROM PUNJABI LANGUAGE.
IF U WANT ANYTHING MORE, PLZ READ SARAIKI LITERATURE.

Mr. Rana.

Saraiki has its own grammer and Phonetics.

IN 1998, ACADMY ADBIYAT PUBLISHED A REPORT IN WHICH IT IS STATED THAT AFTER URDU SERAIKI LITERATURE IS THE MORE PUBLISHED ONE THAN ANY OTHER PAKISTANI LANGUAGE.

If u want to know about HEROEs of saraiki, read Akram Mirani's Book "ASADA DES".

IF U WANT TO READ ABOUT SERAIKI CULTURE, THEN READ FIDA HUSSAIN GADI'S BOOK "SERAIKI CULTURE.

SERAIKI IS TAUGHT IN 2 UNIVERISITES OF PAKISTAN AT BACHELOR AND MASTER LEVEL, IT MEANS THAT THIS IS THE COMPLETELY DIFFERENT LANGAUAGE HAVING ITS OWN GRAMMER AND EVERYTHING WHICH IS REQURED.

DR. C. SHECKEL, GEORGE GRESON AND SOMERNOF HAVE ALSO RECOGNIZED IT AS A DIFFERENT LANGUAGE FROM PUNJABI LANGUAGE.
IF U WANT ANYTHING MORE, PLZ READ SARAIKI LITERATURE.

GOD MAY BLESS U WITH KNOWLEDGE, TOLERANCE AND REALISTIC APPROACH.

FAROOQ DHAREJA-MULTAN

Post edited by: DHAREJA, at: 2006/07/18 10:35

Mr Rana
Where r u living? I mean on earth or any other planet. How u dare to post such shit of anti-seraki and anti-nationalist drive. Be rational and realistic.
Search Wikipedia, a neutral source of information. Here u will find that Seraiki is a language mostly spoken in the provinces of Sindh and the Punjab in central Pakistan by about 14,000,000 people, as well as by about 20,000 people in India, and an immigrant population in the United Kingdom and posseses its own culture and traditions.

Post edited by: hamzailyas, at: 2006/07/20 12:58

Post edited by: hamzailyas, at: 2006/07/20 13:04

Hi Folks,
i will add just one thing here to close this topic.
That there is a tact(psychological+ in negetive journalism)to take and to divert discussion from basic to ,,,,no-point.BY( knowingly)asking childish questions.
Now what should we do now to teach A B C or to get involved and waste of time?
no.we should keep our discussions up to the standards not like this rana,s jolk.

Rana Aslam Ramzan Sb. today I read you massage and I was so strange, to know your opinion. How you can say that Seraiki have no background? and no body knows in the world about Seraiki. Your opinion that there are few thousand peoples of Seraiki is not correct, our Seraiki language have a waste area if you can fairly examine (which is impossible for you). No doubt as a Muslims our culture is same, but region vise our Seraiki area have its own identity and culture like your Punjabi. So it’s our right to demand for a sprit Province and fight for our rights and resources.

We are sorry to say that not only we can’t stop this site but we will fight to get our own Province.

...pa jee fer te urdu arbi te arbi abrani da lehja hoiga
french english te english german da lehja....whats the diff btwn lehja te language....??all pakistani languages
are dialect of hindi???